PROVINCETOWN — In two separate letters, Provincetown Fire Chief Mike Trovato and 18 members of the town’s “call,” or volunteer, fire dept. announced their intention to resign as of midnight on July 2.
Trovato, who joined the fire dept. in 1975 and has been chief for 33 years, sent his resignation letter to town staff on June 17.
At the June 24 select board meeting, 15 volunteer firefighters led by Firemen’s Association President George Felton came to the front of the room during the public comments period and announced they would resign from the department as well, citing Town Manager Alex Morse’s effort to abolish the board of fire engineers at town meeting on April 1 and subsequent conflicts between Morse and Trovato.
“We suggest the select board and town manager take immediate steps to fix this situation, and also issue a public apology to Chief Trovato,” the letter from the 18 firefighters concluded.
Signers of the letter include nearly the entire leadership of engines 1, 2, 3, and 5, according to the call dept. roster on the town’s website.
The select board had scheduled an executive session for its July 24 meeting to discuss with Trovato “personnel issues raised within the fire dept.,” Morse told the Independent. Trovato was notified of that executive session and submitted his resignation rather than attend it, Morse said.
Trovato told the Independent that he did not want to quit, but he felt Morse did not want him to serve as chief any longer.
“I really didn’t want to retire, but when your boss tells you that you’ve ruined the department you spent 49 years to build, that you’ve created a hostile work environment, and that it would be in the best interests of the town and the fire dept. that you retire, what do you think I’m going to do, hang around?” Trovato said. “He pushed me out the door.”
Trovato said the criticisms were made during a May 2 meeting between Trovato, Morse, and Assistant Town Manager Dan Riviello.
Provincetown’s human resources director Katie Buckley helped arrange that meeting but was not present, Trovato said.
Morse and Riviello said they did not tell Trovato at that meeting that he was “ruining the department” or that it was “in the best interest of town that he retire.”
“We never used either of those phrases when meeting with the chief,” Morse told the Independent. “It’s unfortunate if that’s what he took from that conversation, but we merely raised issues brought to us to him. He was the one who said he thought it would be best if he retired.”
Those issues included a complaint from inside the department over the speed at which the town’s new full-time firefighters are being trained to assume certain duties, including driving fire engines, Trovato told the Independent.
“I know my personnel’s capabilities, and I know when someone’s ready to drive a fire truck,” Trovato said. “We were working on it.”
Riviello told the select board on May 28 that concerns about the training being afforded to full-time staff were the reason the May 2 meeting was called.
“We respect Chief Trovato and the call volunteers,” Rivello said, “but we also respect our new full-time staff and have concerns about their training.”
Meeting Fallout
The differing accounts of that May 2 meeting have contributed to the present divide.
The Provincetown Firemen’s Association wrote a letter objecting to Trovato’s treatment on May 2 that was read aloud by Firefighter Malcolm Hunter at the May 28 select board meeting.
The resignation letter that Felton read to the select board on June 24 also cited the “extreme disrespect” that Trovato was shown that day.
“We believe Chief Trovato has never made the fire dept. a hostile workplace,” the resignation letter said, “and rather than go by the words of one or two members, Morse should have reached out to the department as a whole to get the opinions of everyone.”
Morse told the select board on June 24 that “there are two sides to the story. I welcomed the fire chief to stay, and today I met with former Deputy Chief Jimmy Roderick, who agreed today to come back to the department to help retain our call volunteers.”
Roderick will serve as acting fire chief beginning July 2, Morse confirmed the next day, and EMS coordinator Othaine Rance will be deputy fire chief.
Roderick and Rance will both be on the board of fire engineers, Morse told the Independent, as will “call” firefighter Capt. David Gonsalves, EMS shift supervisor Michael Anderson, and Human Resources Director Buckley.
“A lot of folks think we’re going to bring some bogeyman in from out of town and that’s going to change the entire department,” Morse told the select board on June 24. “We have the talent internally, and the volunteer firefighters who resigned today are invited to my office tomorrow to have a conversation about what they need to stay in this department.”
The Decision to Retire
In a statement posted on the town’s website on June 25, Morse wrote that “per state law, Chief Trovato would have had to retire less than a year from now.” Trovato is 69, and a special extension to the state’s mandatory retirement age for fire chiefs will expire when he turns 70 next June.
The department still has 20 career firefighter-medics, two staff people, and 27 call volunteers, Morse wrote. The firefighter-medics were hired over the last year as part of a long-term plan for a “combination department” that will include full-time staff “supported and supplemented by call volunteers,” Morse wrote.
Morse also wrote that he was disappointed in the firefighters who publicly resigned on June 24.
“Using the public comment period of a meeting to announce their retirements” was meant to scare people, Morse wrote. “While cynical, I understand that the goal of their tactics was to capture the attention of the public and instill fear throughout our community.
“It’s my job to make sure residents know that we are confident in our ability to provide the needed fire and EMS coverage as we approach peak season in Provincetown,” Morse continued.
Morse also wrote that he hoped the volunteers’ “allegiance to the town will outweigh their allegiance to one man who made the decision to retire.”
The letter from the firefighters who resigned says they believe Trovato was told to quit.
The select board did not discuss the resignations at length on June 24 as it was not on their agenda, but they did speak about it in their opening statements.
“Things will change at the fire department, they will evolve and they have to, but we need to make room for the people who have been protecting us and serving us for so long,” said select board member Erik Borg.
“Change is hard, and I was hoping this could have been a respectful process,” said board member Leslie Sandberg. “This is sad, what happened tonight.”