Queer baby boomers are now elders, the first generation to grow old after Stonewall. They came of age in a world where it was possible to love openly, keep one’s job, and even get married, much like their straight counterparts. But not exactly. Their regrets, yearnings, fears, and satisfactions are unique, because each person’s experience growing up with the shame of being queer and, as an adult, navigating the pitfalls of sexuality and romance, shapes the individual’s worldview in old age.
Which brings me to Zigzag, Philip Gambone’s marvelous new short story collection about aging gay men in the Boston area, particularly white men who spent their formative years in the South End. The book makes it clear that personal liberation is a lifelong and universal pursuit.
Such wisdom might seem obvious, and it may elicit an unsympathetic “tut-tut” by those fed up with white male privilege. But to the gay men in Gambone’s stories, the path to self-knowledge and emotional fulfillment is filled with thorny obstacles and, in some cases, dead ends. These fictional boomers are both proving and disproving the cliché that “old age isn’t for sissies.”
Gambone is an extraordinarily good writer, though his work has usually been relegated to the queer lit sections of bookstores and websites because of his subjects. Zigzag is his second short-story collection (after The Language We Use Up Here), and he has also written a novel (Beijing) and some notable nonfiction: Something Inside: Conversations with Gay Fiction Writers; Travels in a Gay Nation: Portraits of LGBTQ Americans; and a remarkable memoir, As Far as I Can Tell: Finding My Father in World War II, which I reviewed in the Provincetown Independent in 2021. Now retired, he spent his life teaching high-school English and college-level writing in the Boston area. He’s a frequent visitor to Provincetown and lives, during the colder months, in San Miguel de Allende, Mexico.
Gambone’s prose is clear and mostly unembellished with literary flourishes. His sentences flow effortlessly in a conversational rhythm (either third person or first). He is strikingly efficient with detail and description, offering just enough about clothes, décor, and appearance to enhance one’s understanding of character and setting but not so much as to create an indulgent soup of symbolism. He’s a skilled storyteller, holding back enough to keep his reader continually engaged, but character is his thing: the people and narrators who populate Zigzag’s 16 stories are complex, relatable, and very much themselves, whether they’re humorous, irritating, or lovable, or a combination of the three.
For example, there’s Mason Chastain in “The Hazardous Life,” a high-school French teacher nearing retirement who embarks on teaching a senior-level French literature course and falls for one of his most promising male students. Mason is in the closet, having been married to a lesbian for 44 years and faithful — emotionally, at least — till her death. There’s also the letter carrier Sam and his younger husband, Daryl, in “Big Boy,” who encounter a wealthy couple, Monroe and Richard, as they walk through the South End. Sam and Daryl have an open relationship within certain boundaries, which these new friends end up challenging. Then there’s the HR counselor Alan, in “Human Resources,” who lives in a bungalow in Mattapan with another single gay roommate in his 60s. Alan gets his jollies hooking up at seedy motels with an Egyptian donut-shop owner, Najib, who’s married to a woman and the father of a little girl. Where does it all lead? To tears and confessions and reassurances, of course, but the journey in all of Gambone’s stories is full of both predictable outcomes and startling surprises.
There’s a fair amount of gay male sex, too, some of it explicit, and if that’s a red flag for you as a reader, then Zigzag may not be easy to take. But what’s erotic in the book is not gratuitous, and Gambone is never vulgar in spirit. Besides, there’s a fair amount of unrequited attraction among his characters, and all of the sexually charged scenes, whether consummated or not, are really about character. Though much of gay life after Stonewall is defined by sexual liberation, Gambone is looking for a broader kind of fulfillment.
Indeed, the stories in this collection are tied together by more than just age, orientation, and proximity to the South End. Religion often comes into play, as does social striving and the effects of gentrification. “Zigzag,” the titular final story, corrals characters from several other stories in the book into an art gallery opening reception in Dorchester. The effect is interesting but not climactic. It reinforces Gambone’s themes and the sense of community among disparate characters, but it also underlines his ambivalence about the right and wrong choices in life. The book focuses on old age, and the gay men in its pages reflect frequently on the past. But Gambone’s thrust is the present. And the present, in life and in fiction, is open-ended.