Join the Center for Coastal Studies for a field walk through Hatches Harbor in Provincetown on Saturday, May 8th, from 1 to 3 p.m. Poet Elizabeth Bradfield and biologist Lisa Sette will lead you on a two-mile walk. Be sure to wear comfortable shoes and bring binoculars. Registration is $25 at coastalstudies.org.
Center for Coastal Studies
Thar She Blows
It’s a virtual Moby-Dick Week at the Provincetown Public Library. On Thursday, May 6th, at 6 p.m. the Center for Coastal Studies presents “Right Whales: A Species on the Brink.” On Friday, May 7th, at 6 p.m., join “Whaling Captains of Color,” a talk by Skip Finley. But the highlight will be “Squeeze! Squeeze! Squeeze! Moby-Dick: The Queerest Book We Never Knew,” a talk by Philip Hoare on Saturday, May 8th, at noon. Email [email protected] for the Zoom link.
Thar She Blows
It’s a virtual Moby-Dick Week at the Provincetown Public Library. On Thursday, May 6th, at 6 p.m. the Center for Coastal Studies presents “Right Whales: A Species on the Brink.” On Friday, May 7th, at 6 p.m., join “Whaling Captains of Color,” a talk by Skip Finley. But the highlight will be “Squeeze! Squeeze! Squeeze! Moby-Dick: The Queerest Book We Never Knew,” a talk by Philip Hoare on Saturday, May 8th, at noon. Email [email protected] for the Zoom link.
Cleanup Act
Join the Center for Coastal Studies for a beach cleanup on Saturday, May 1st, from 7:30 to 9:30 a.m. It will take place on an Outer Cape beach — exact location to be determined. Email [email protected] for more information.
Bottled Up
The Center for Coastal Studies and CARE for the Cape and Islands present “Changing Behaviors Changing the Game,” part two of their webinar series on the municipal and commercial single-use water bottle ban, on Thursday, April 29th, at 10 a.m. Registration is free at careforthecapeandislands.org.
Good Clean Fun
Celebrate Earth Day with a beach or park cleanup on Thursday, April 22nd, hosted by the Center for Coastal Studies. Register by emailing [email protected]. Don’t forget to wear gloves and take pictures as documentation.
Whale Search
Join the Center for Coastal Studies for a guided whale walk on Friday, April 2nd, from 10 to 11:30 a.m. Meet at Herring Cove to look for humpback, fin, and minke whales. Be sure to wear comfortable shoes! Registration is $10, limited to 10, at coastalstudies.org.
WHALE WATCH
Three Mother-Calf Pairs Are Bright Spot in Dismal Reality
In Cape Cod Bay, scientists count one-fourth of the world’s remaining North Atlantic right whales
PROVINCETOWN — The Center for Coastal Studies (CCS) March 3 sighting of Millipede, a 16-year-old North Atlantic right whale, and her newborn calf — the season’s first — in Cape Cod Bay made headlines across the Cape. Now, the CCS has more good news.
This Week In Wellfleet
Meetings Ahead
Meetings are held remotely. From wellfleet-ma.gov, hover over a date on the calendar on the right of the screen and click on the meeting you’re interested in to open its agenda and find out how to view and take part remotely.
Thursday, March 25
- School Committee Superintendent Search Subcommittee, 10:15 a.m.
- Zoning Board of Appeals, 7 p.m.
Friday, March 26
- Bike and Walkways Committee, 9 a.m.
Monday, March 29
- Dredging Task Force, 7 p.m.
Tuesday, March 30
- Elections: Districtwide Nauset Regional H.S. Project and Special Town Election, 11 a.m. to 7 p.m.
Conversation Starters
Curley Report Revisited
The Natural Resources Advisory Board (NRAB) and the Center for Coastal Studies (CCS) hope to replicate a 1972 survey of marine resources in Wellfleet Harbor. Owen Nichols, director of marine fisheries research at the CCS, and John Riehl, chair of NRAB, presented the proposed project at the Shellfish Advisory Board meeting on March 17, and the board voted to support it.
The original survey, known as the Curley Report, was conducted by the Mass. Div. of Marine Fisheries and involved systematic sampling and inventorying of species. The authors recommended replicating the study every 10 years. Now, nearly 50 years later, the NRAB is drafting a warrant article seeking funds for the project at town meeting this spring.
As recommended in the March 2021 Harbor Management Plan, the year-long project would investigate the flora and fauna in the harbor. This would, as written in the draft article, establish a “basis for future actions to preserve and enhance this environment.”
The survey would develop a framework for long-term monitoring, said Nichols. In planning the project, they are seeking input from the community to determine which questions should be asked. “As we plan this project, you will have a say in what happens,” said Riehl. —Tessera Knowles-Thompson
Whale of a Time
Join the Center for Coastal Studies for a guided whale walk on Saturday, March 27th, from 2 to 3:30 p.m. You’ll meet at Herring Cove and look for humpback, fin, and minke whales. Registration is $10, limited to 12, at coastalstudies.org.
ENVIRONMENT
Study Finds Nutrients Increase Coastal Acidification
A new council is proposed in hopes of protecting shellfish
WELLFLEET — With a minus-0.6-foot low tide at 5:11 p.m. and the sun setting at 5:26, Bob Wallace and Mattias Christensen have no time to lose. Their oysters have been overwintering in concrete pits on land for the past five weeks. Now, on this late February evening, the shellfishermen are returning them to the flats. When the tide reaches its lowest point, they move on to the work of breaking apart clusters of oysters.
“Shellfishermen are observers,” says Wallace, while confidently using a hatchet to separate a cluster. “You’re just reacting to what Mother Nature throws at you.”
He points to an oyster with a blackened shell, picked out of the muck. The dark color, he explains, signifies hypoxia — this oyster did not get enough oxygen in the substrate. Most of the other oysters appear to be fine — near perfect, in fact — and the two shellfishermen continue their work.
For shellfishermen, reacting to Mother Nature is just one part of the battle. They are now faced with the rising threat of ocean and coastal acidification — a reduced pH environment in which mollusks (like oysters, clams, and scallops), with their calcium carbonate shells, are particularly vulnerable.
Ocean acidification, a global threat, is one of the consequences of carbon dioxide emissions. Coastal acidification is driven locally by nutrient pollution and resulting eutrophication — excessive growth of marine plants and algae. Both are caused by human activities.
Wallace has already witnessed eutrophication in action. “More and more weeds are suffocating the oysters,” says Wallace, who was one of the members of a 2015 working group on climate change impacts on shellfishing in Wellfleet Harbor. Nutrients like nitrogen and phosphorous feed phytoplankton, which feed oysters, Wallace explains, but the rapid growth of aquatic plants can also suffocate the oysters.
While neither Wallace nor Christensen has seen the effects of coastal acidification yet, they know what to look for; they know more acidic conditions make it more challenging for shells to form; they know the shellfish are most vulnerable in their larval stage of growth.
Now, the state is confirming what local shellfishermen have long worried about. According to a report researched by a governor-appointed commission of lawmakers, scientists, and fishermen and released on Feb. 9, the threat of coastal acidification represents a crisis for Massachusetts. “The degree of harm that occurs,” the report states, “depends on the extent of mitigation efforts undertaken now.”
A key finding: land-based nutrient pollution “amplifies localized differences in pH.” That means the eutrophication shellfishermen are already observing is likely a sign local acidification is on the way.
On the upside: many of the land-based sources of the problem, from golf course runoff to septic system discharge, are controllable.
Last month, in response to the report, state Sen. Julian Cyr and state Rep. Sarah Peake, both members of the commission, co-sponsored companion bills in the House and Senate that would tackle acidification in our coastal waters. “If we don’t find a way to mitigate ocean acidification,” Cyr told the Independent, “the marine economy is very much at risk.”
That risk is especially high on the Outer Cape, where in Wellfleet alone “about 450 people make their livings in the shellfishing industry,” said Nancy Civetta, the town’s shellfish constable. Her figure includes wild harvesters as well as farmers and their employees. “That is 15 percent of Wellfleet’s total year-round population and 25 percent of its working-age population,” Civetta added.
“Aquaculture has been a bright spot in the economy in a place that would otherwise be unaffordable to many young people,” said Cyr.
One of the key features of the legislation is the establishment of a permanent council on ocean acidification. The council would commission independent studies to “fill acidification knowledge gaps.” It would also coordinate public and private monitoring efforts, provide monitoring hardware and technical training, and maintain a central repository for acidification data.
Local monitoring efforts are already underway, but the bill would expand their reach and longevity. The Center for Coastal Studies in Provincetown has been monitoring water quality in Wellfleet and Provincetown harbors since 2006, said Amy Costa, director of the center’s Cape Cod Bay Monitoring Program. Last year, two different projects began focusing their attention on measuring pH and the effects of acidification.
Wellfleet is still working on its state Dept. of Environmental Protection watershed permit, which will propose a range of nutrient-mitigating projects to bring the town into compliance with Section 208 of the U.S. Clean Water Act. Some of the proposed waste treatment plans being considered — from salt marsh restoration and shellfish propagation to nitrogen-reducing sewage systems — could also help fight acidification.
For example, Civetta said she and Assistant Constable Johnny Mankevetch are working with the town’s wastewater committee to include a budget for sea clam shells in the watershed permit application. The shells would be used as cultch — material on which oyster spat is grown — but could also potentially add more calcium carbonate to the substrate. Civetta said she has more work to do “to understand just how much shell deployment would be necessary to actually have a significant mitigating effect” on acidification.
Ginny Parker, president of the Wellfleet Shellfishermen’s Association, said that her organization’s goal is to make sure “the voices and expertise of the Outer Cape shellfishermen are heard.” She envisions them as members of the permanent ocean acidification council, “because these decisions will have long-term effects.”
Free as a Bird
The Center for Coastal Studies is presenting a virtual lecture, “Cape Cod Seabird Rehab 101,” presented by Stephanie Ellis, executive director of Wild Care, on Wednesday, February 24th, at 7 p.m. Registration is free at coastalstudies.org.
currents
This Week In Eastham
Meetings Ahead
Meetings are held remotely. Go to eastham-ma.gov/calendar-by-event-type/16 and click on a particular meeting to read its agenda. That document will provide information about how to view and take part remotely.
Thursday, Feb. 4
- Cultural Council, 6:30 p.m.
Monday, Feb. 8
- Select Board, 5:30 p.m.
Tuesday, Feb. 9
- Conservation Commission, 6 p.m.
Wednesday, Feb. 10
- Finance Committee, 5 p.m.
- Nauset High School Building Project meeting, 6:30 p.m.
Conversation Starters
Covid-19 Update
As of Jan. 28, Eastham had 21 new cases within the preceding 14 days and 78 total cases to date, according to the Mass. Dept. of Public Health weekly Covid-19 report. No Eastham Covid-19 deaths have been reported.
Farmers to Families
USDA Farmers to Families weekly food box distribution will be coming to the Elks Lodge in Eastham starting Monday, Feb. 8. The boxes contain about 32 pounds of perishable food, including milk, fresh fruits and vegetables, and cooked meat.
Although the USDA’s distribution partner is the Mass. Military Support Foundation, select board member Aimee Eckman stressed the program is open to veterans and non-veterans alike. Participants must sign up for the weekly distributions on the MMSF website, mmsfi.org. A copy of the email confirming registration will be required to pick up the food boxes at the lodge on Mondays from 2:30 to 4:30 p.m.
Anyone needing assistance with registering or arranging for pickup and delivery can contact Eckman via text or phone at 508-237-9724 or email at [email protected].
Eckman also encouraged anyone needing help with food, rent, utilities, or other living expenses to contact the Lower Cape Outreach Council at 508-240-0694 or at [email protected].
Drones Banned From Federal Land Flyovers
In September 2020, the Center for Coastal Studies had to delay phase one of the Nauset Marsh study that was to include creating a high-resolution 3D map of the area, because of a ban on drones. It had already scrubbed its April 2020 launch due to the return of plovers. Now, only temporarily, it is hoped, all drone flights over federal lands are banned, coastal geologist Mark Borrelli told the select board during an update on the project.
“This had to do with the previous administration,” Borelli said. “I’m not going to get into too many details, but they basically banned drones made in China. They weren’t allowed to fly over federal land.”
The center has two drones, he said, one that was made in China and another that was made in New Hampshire. The group moved forward with plans to use the New Hampshire-made drone.
“By the time we jumped through all the hoops,” Borrelli said, “it turned out some of the components in the drone made in New Hampshire were actually made in China.
“The Seashore feels horrible about this,” Borrelli said. “They’re scientists. They want to get this stuff done,” and, he added, “they love drones.”
Borrelli believes the drones will be allowed to fly again by September, but he does have a Plan B, which would be to use an RTK (real-time kinematic) GPS unit attached to an ATV and drive up and down the beach for a couple of hours.
“It’s collecting data every second,” he said. “You can create a really nice surface model from it,” though, “admittedly, it’s not as good as a drone.”
While Plan B would be completed by spring, should the drone ban be lifted by September, that mapping would be done as well. “You’ll just get two maps,” Borelli said.
While phase one is in a holding pattern, phase two has continued, Borelli reported, with samples being taken from 25 stations throughout the marsh to be analyzed, and seine sampling and vessel-based surveys also continuing.
The project is expected to be completed by June 2021.
—Linda Culhane
ENVIRONMENT
Wellfleet Harbor’s ‘Black Custard’
It’s all-natural, but you wouldn’t want to eat it
WELLFLEET — Agnes Mittermayr, a marine ecologist at the Center for Coastal Studies (CCS) in Provincetown, has coined a new term to describe the dark, sludgy material that fills Wellfleet Harbor: “black custard.”
“Initially, everyone called it ‘mayo,’ ” she said.
Making Waves
The Center for Coastal Studies in Provincetown is presenting “Sea Change Film Shorts 2020,” a short film program available for free streaming through Monday, November 23rd. It includes three shorts: “Spinnaker,” a film about the life and death of a humpback whale, and two films about microplastics. Register at coastalstudies.org.