PROVINCETOWN — The town’s 46th annual Carnival parade moved down Commercial Street with its typical buoyance on Aug. 22: painted props and bodies glittered in sunlight, and floats sent out waves of music that set the gathered revelers spinning and singing.
Carnival
IN VIEW THIS WEEK
A Quiet Carnival Week
Provincetown hosted a quiet but still colorful Carnival this year. Costumed cowardly lions and other characters from Oz roamed the streets throughout last week. (Photo Edward Boches)
PROVINCETOWN: THIS WEEK'S CURRENTS
Carnival, Vaxxed
Meetings Ahead
Some Provincetown meetings are in-person only, some are remote only, and some are a hybrid where you can choose to participate in person or through a remote link. Go to provincetown-ma.gov, click on the meeting you want to watch, and follow the instructions on the agenda.
Thursday, August 12
- Board of Health, Town Hall, 4 p.m.
- Planning Board, Town Hall, 6 p.m.
Tuesday, August 17
- Conservation Commission, Town Hall, 6 p.m.
Conversation Starters
Carnival, Vaxxed
As part of the town’s and business community’s efforts to promote safety during Carnival Week, which kicks off on Aug. 15, the board of health is offering three certifications to local businesses, depending on their Covid vaccination policies. A business can be certified if the venue requires all staff to be vaccinated, if the venue requires proof of vaccination to enter, or if all staff are vaccinated and the venue requires proof of vaccination, according to the town’s website.
As of the Independent’s deadline on Tuesday, Aug. 10, 48 businesses had the status of “fully vaccinated,” 14 had the status of “fully vaccinated & requires proof of vaccine,” and two were listed as “waiting for form.”
Keep Your Mask On
Provincetown’s indoor mask mandate will remain in place at least until Saturday, Aug. 21, according to the Covid information page on the town’s website. The mandate covers all indoor public spaces, including performance venues, restaurants, bars, retail shops, fitness centers, and offices. Unvaccinated people, including children under 12, are required to wear masks in outdoor settings where crowding prevents social distancing. Free Covid tests and vaccinations are available daily, from 10 a.m. to 3 p.m., at 2 Mayflower St.
As of the Independent’s Tuesday, Aug. 10 deadline, active cases among Provincetown residents numbered 14. That was a decline from 23 on Aug. 9, the website stated. The test positivity rate (that is, the percentage of positive tests out of all tests) had fallen from a peak of 15.1 percent on Thursday, July 15 to 4.3 percent on Monday, Aug. 9. While a test positivity rate of less than 5 percent is considered “progress towards cluster containment,” a rate of less than one percent is an indication of containment, according to the Barnstable County Dept. of Health and Environment. —Sophie Hills
FEAR ITSELF
Walking Carnival Parade Nixed for This August
Select board bows to police chief’s fears for public health
PROVINCETOWN — The theme for the 43rd Carnival parade, “Somewhere Over the Rainbow,” was supposed to evoke a return to the good life after the long pandemic. But the select board’s June 14 denial of the parade application means that dream will not come true this year.
The Provincetown Business Guild (PBG) had pitched a different kind of cavalcade for this summer — one that would have included people on bikes, “pedi-cabs, shopping carts, wagons, pulled carts, golf carts, scooters, and an estimated 1,000 marchers,” according to the application for the Aug. 19 parade on Commercial Street.
Gone would be the floats, of which there were 60 in all, including 40 large ones on trucks, in the 2019 parade — the largest in Carnival history. These floats are the focus of a good deal of event safety planning. Each one requires the work of four “parade wranglers,” who must march beside the trucks’ wheels to keep people from swarming around the vehicles and having their feet run over, or stopping the parade flow, said Robert Sanborn, the guild’s executive director.
But the select board, which wields the authority to grant parade permits, voted 3-1 against the PBG’s proposal. Chair David Abramson was absent and John Golden cast the lone vote in favor of the truckless extravaganza. Police Chief Jim Golden (who is not related to select board member John Golden) said he feared the parade would not keep rolling without the usual vehicles.
The select board’s Golden said he was “baffled” by this reasoning. He thought those marching in high heels would want to step as fast as possible to get all the way from the Harbor Hotel in the far East End to Franklin Street.
Sanborn said the board’s decision “was a vote against tourism.”
“We were offering a safer alternative, and I didn’t understand the rationale for voting against it,” Sanborn continued. “I believe there will be an organic, unorganized costume promenade anyway,” he said, “and we missed the opportunity to make it organized and safer.”
Louise Venden, the board member who moved that the parade application be denied, said she did not want to overtax the police. The town has seen record numbers of tourists since May, and she said she feared a Carnival parade organized starting now would be too much with too little planning.
Venden also referred to the concerns listed in a letter to the board from the police chief. These included the suggestion that public health calls for reducing the scale of events and limiting contact among people.
The letter also cited the lack of planning time. Parade organization generally begins six months before the event, the chief wrote. The select board voted in April to cancel the parade and, as recently as two weeks ago, the PBG, town staff, and police met to discuss a street festival rather than a moving parade during Carnival week.
But the street festival, which also requires permitting by the select board, was then rejected by the business community, which favored a parade, Sanborn said.
Town Manager Alex Morse said the police chief had neither rejected nor endorsed the parade idea. Instead, he had attached some conditions, including reimbursement from the PBG for extra police staff.
No one could question Chief Golden directly because he did not attend the meeting.
“This is one of the things disappointing to me,” said Venden. “When a member of town staff is not available to us. We don’t have anyone who can explain this to us.”
She said there were too many questions left unanswered.
Sanborn said if the PBG now wants to go back to having a street festival it must ask the select board at its next meeting, at the end of June. That leaves less than two months to plan the festival. It may be too late.
At this point, it may just be an “express yourself day,” Sanborn said. That’s a new idea by the PBG that invites participants during each of the LGBTQ theme weeks to dress to express themselves, he said. Carnival parade day 2021 could become “Somewhere Over the Rainbow,” the informal costume party.
STEAMERS
Virtual Carnival
QUIET SUMMER
No July 4 Fireworks; Parade Permits Are Rescinded
Business survey finds strong support for precautions
PROVINCETOWN — With a flat tone and zero arguments, the select board on Monday rescinded parade permits and banned the use of town property through Dec. 31, in effect canceling the Fourth of July fireworks and parade and the Carnival parade.
All that the town’s elected leaders debated Monday night was whether to cancel events only through Aug. 31, which was the initial suggestion by town staff, or to extend the ban through the end of the year.
The end of the year made sense, they decided, because various organizations can re-apply to hold events with new rules when more is known about Gov. Charlie Baker’s four-phase re-opening plans. The select board briefly mentioned the Provincetown 400 events, which have been scheduled for the fall, as fitting into the category of wait-and-see.
As for the summer, however, Provincetown’s most celebrated events won’t happen, will be greatly constrained, or will be relegated to the virtual.
The Provincetown Portuguese Festival, scheduled for late June, will exist this year only as the Blessing of the Fleet. That is, the boats will still be blessed on MacMillan Pier, as usual; but it will be a much quieter day, similar to the first blessing in 1948, according to an announcement from the festival organizers. The exact timing is still to be determined. The organizers will, however, decorate the streets with Portuguese flags and paint the pavement with Portuguese roosters. A booklet and a T-shirt featuring a painting by Truro artist Thomas A.D. Watson will be for sale online.
Businesses and visitors were already mourning the cancellation of Bear Week, Pride Week, Family Week, and the Provincetown International Film Festival, all major draws of the annual summer tourist season.
Radu Luca, executive director of the Provincetown Chamber of Commerce, was as quiet as the select board when he described the state of Provincetown’s business community.
He referred to a survey of local businesses by the Provincetown Recovery Coalition, which found that 62 percent say they will need additional disaster relief funding to survive.
Luca said the Monkey Bar and one other restaurant, which he would not name, have already decided not to open at all this year.
Reservations in guest houses and hotels are currently down by 20 to 60 percent from last year, Luca said.
Bob Sanborn, executive director of the Provincetown Business Guild, said once Gov. Baker announces new rules on May 18, the recovery coalition will try to make decisions in the following two weeks on how Provincetown can adapt.
The business community survey found broad support (90 percent) for continued social distancing, enhanced sanitation, and contactless payments. Close to 80 percent of the respondents said they plan to open this summer, with 20 percent not sure. About 72 percent said they would remain open later in the year to compensate for lost business.
Business owners were slightly more divided (67 percent in favor) about turning a section of Commercial Street into a pedestrian mall for a portion of the day.
And a majority of businesses would like relaxed restrictions in public spaces to allow outside display for retail, pop-up tents and gallery stroll nights, public picnic areas on town property, and expanded restaurant service to adjacent outside areas including the sidewalks and beach areas, according to Leslie Sandberg, the spokesperson for the recovery coalition.
“Basically our objective is to manage the people who come to Provincetown in a safe way,” Sanborn said.
Provincetown
Enchanted Forest 2019
"Everybody needed some joy"
Photos by Marcia Geier taken at this year’s Carnival parade, with words collected online and in conversations afterwards by Susannah Elisabeth Fulcher.
PROVINCETOWN — “Joy in the street!” The words of longtime Provincetown visitor and now year-round renter Barbara Dyett perfectly captured the mood of this year’s Enchanted Forest Carnival Parade. The costumes were magical and the sense of freedom to become another fantastical creature for a day was palpable throughout town. “Everybody needed some joy,” Dyett added.
Lea DeLaria was the Grand Marshall this year, shepherding along a parade of magical creatures, exuberantly living out this year’s Enchanted Forest theme.
“It was amazing,” agreed Eddy Lupien Jr., who manages the Carpe Diem Guesthouse and is a fixture on the Provincetown Business Guild’s first float as Drag Queen Drunkerella. “The energy was great even though the weather was hot!”
Even Provincetown resident Lee Reis, who was not always a lover of the event, was convinced this year: “During the second half of summer patience starts to wear thin, traffic is awful, there’s a crowd everywhere. I’ve learned to embrace the love and fun and shared amazement of our fabulous little town.”
Elves like this one contributed to the mood for people like Reis, who added that the parade offered a great excuse to be a tourist for a day.
There were moments of irony. And of fine art.
People flocked into town from throughout the Cape and beyond, lining Commercial Street from early in the morning to watch the many floats and costumed participants parade by. One after another, they charmed onlookers. Sometimes with the happy simplicity of bubbles and tutus and fairy wings and flowers. Other times with deep woods special effects.
“To celebrate diversity and embrace acceptance was clearly the theme, as evidenced by the smiles and laughter throughout the afternoon,” said Eastham resident Jan Dowsett Potter. She was not alone in offering “kudos to the police and DPW for keeping us all safe and for the cleanup afterward. “That not a single negative incident occurred speaks volumes about this wonderful Cape Cod community.”
Photographer Marcia Geier lives in Wellfleet but makes her photographs in many places, including cities and zoos. Susannah Elisabeth Fulcher lives with her family in Wellfleet, where she is working on a novel and a memoir about her experience with cancer treatment. Both contribute regularly to the Independent.
THE YEAR-ROUNDER
Sanctuary and Balance
Our hallmark should be respect for all, including ourselves
PROVINCETOWN — Sailing or motoring out of Cape Cod Bay, rounding Long Point and entering Provincetown Harbor, there is a sense of protected water. The harbor appears as a big round bowl, the rims running from the shores of Truro through the crowded town waterfront, backed by dunes, and out to the Point. Refuge.
Indeed, it was just about 400 years ago that the Mayflower made its weary way into these waters, and the Pilgrims thanked their God for this protection. And there were explorers before them who made the same discovery. Sanctuary.
And the town itself has also been seen in this same light: refuge for the outcast and beleaguered, what Melville termed “Isolatoes.” The mythology of the place refers to wayward pirates, smugglers, escaped slaves, surviving Native Americans, all mingling and coexisting. There was the appropriately named Hell Town, where all sorts of behavior was either sanctioned or overlooked. As the myth goes, the very genesis of Provincetown occurred when the good citizens of Truro petitioned the Massachusetts General Court to separate them from these rowdies. The year was 1727.
And so it has been ever since. While the early to mid-19th century witnessed a growing and prospering middle class of hard-working Yankee and Portuguese families getting their livelihood from the sea, there was always that aura of independent lives lived on the edge. Some have said that the very physical reality of the place, the outermost extremity of a peninsula, attracts a certain kind of person — someone drawn to the very end, to the place where there is nowhere else to go. Isolatoes.
Of course, there was also the beauty — stark and wondrous dunes, ocean, and bay — and the charm of the little winding streets and lanes, so like a European fishing village. These attributes were foremost in attracting the artists and writers, the freethinkers and free-livers and free-lovers. You all know the names, from Mary Heaton Vorse and Tennessee Williams and Harry Kemp to Norman Mailer and Mary Oliver.
There is one more theory for the independent life styles that have always been a hallmark of life in Provincetown: the open-minded Mediterranean perspective of the Portuguese (a quarter of the town by 1895) allowed for it. If you had a dollar for the room there was absolutely no consideration of what you were doing in it.
I am sure this was true to an extent, but I also have read of the police chief’s vow to “get rid of the Boys” in the 1950s and early 1960s, and I have heard firsthand accounts of older townspeople “beating up the queers” around that time.
Still, overall, Provincetown has been a refuge and sanctuary for people of all persuasions, for at least a century, and certainly in these last 50 years I can attest to a growing movement that goes beyond tolerance to absolute acceptance. I feel so proud to live in a town in which everyone can live freely, without fear of persecution.
A few years ago, when I drove for Art’s Dune Tours, I took six women from South Carolina out for a sunset trip. They had a good time and were a bit rowdy — even randy — and boisterous. One of them said to me on the way back, “You have to understand: we can’t do anything like this back home. We can’t even walk down the street holding hands.” I do understand.
I saw a T-shirt on a woman the other day that read: “Every Town Should Be Provincetown.” I agree.
I revel in the absolute freedom that emanates from the summer crowd thronging Commercial Street. There is a very positive energy in the air, much of it gay.
But now, on the eve of Carnival, I will strike a cautionary note: while in recent years the parade itself has been relatively wholesome and in the spirit of good fun (somewhat evolved from its early years of R- and X-rated floats), one does see examples of outré behavior on the street, especially this week. Some of the outfits worn on the street amount to little more than display cases for genitalia. Some of the slogans I have seen on T-shirts are juvenile, even offensive.
I would remind our revelers that there is a thin line between flaunting and flouting. One can celebrate liberation and still adhere to good taste. With freedom comes responsibility; with sanctuary there must be balance. Hedonism can be tiresome. Exhibitionism is a solitary, even selfish, joy.
The street should be safe and appropriate for all — for children and people who are not really interested in what your particular kink is. The hallmark of our lives should be respect for all, including respect for ourselves. We all, to paraphrase Whitman, contain multitudes: we are not strictly defined by our sexuality or sexual proclivities.
Let’s all celebrate these waning days of summer, when the sun is setting noticeably earlier; let’s welcome all our visitors and join in their celebration of life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness; let’s respect one another.
metaphysics
Forest-Dwellers on the Outer Cape
The enchantment of living on borrowed time
TRURO — “Autumn is over the long leaves that love us,” wrote William Butler Yeats. The first harbingers of autumn are suddenly over the Outer Cape, as we see the sharpening of the colors of the water and feel the chill in the morning air. But the Outer Cape has become more permanently autumnal, as so many people come here to spend their final years among our long leaves. The median age of Wellfleet residents was 62 in 2014; in Truro it is 60; in Eastham, 59. These are people in what the Hindus call the forest-dweller stage of life.
Ancient Hindu texts wisely divide life into three basic stages: in the first, you study; in the second, you marry and become a householder; and in the third, you go and live in the forest. The third stage begins when you see your first gray hairs, or your first grandchild, and then it is time to head for the woods (with your partner if you have one), to live simply but in comfort, and to think about things. It’s where you finally take the wise advice of the Italians: Dolce far niente. It’s sweet to do nothing.
In this, forest-dwelling is the opposite of what many people hope to do in retirement: catch up on all the old goals that got shouldered out of the way by a career or child-rearing. Travel, learn to paint, garden, bake, do pro bono work, speak Italian, play the guitar. Indeed, it is probably the opposite of what the planners of Carnival Week in Provincetown (which begins on Aug. 17) had in mind when they chose this year’s theme: “The Enchanted Forest.” Well, chacun à son forêt.
In fact, forest-dwelling is more a state of mind than a plan of action. It is the time in which things do not matter in the same way they did when we were younger. I take satisfaction in the knowledge that, if I were to die today, no one could possibly say of me, “tragically struck down in her youth.” There’s something liberating about living on borrowed time.
And the forest-dweller discovers the pleasures of solitude, of what in earlier life would have been wasting time, watching the waves streaming in onto the beach, listening to the wind in the trees, looking at the dance of the clouds in the sky, watching the red-tailed hawks cruising in the marsh. The treasure you find in the forest is silence, the absence of the white noise of what other people think is the real world. The ultimate forest in the Outer Cape is the dune shack, but any structure will do as long as you can be alone in it and away from Amazon and Facebook and all that jazz.
For the Hindus who perfected this system, the object of your meditation should be philosophical; you should be working out your own take on the meaning of life. For those of us who are not Hindus, the mental goal is wide open. One classical Indian metaphor for the ideal state of mind is the surface of water on which there have ceased to be any distracting ripples of anger and desire, so that you can look down through the now still surface into the depth where the secret meaning is found.
For the Outer Cape forest-dweller, I think the ripples themselves may be the meaning, the rippled patterns of life, memory, chagrin, happiness, regret, loss, all that was obscured by the waves of striving to achieve it but now is there for us to contemplate, becalmed among the long leaves that love us.